Talk:Trainmen and engineers go on statewide strike in New Jersey, first time in 42 years
Review of revision 4857985 [Not ready]
| |
Revision 4857985 of this article has been reviewed by Gryllida (talk · contribs) and found not ready at 10:39, 17 May 2025 (UTC).
Comments by reviewer: Hi @George Ho @Wikiwide @BigKrow @Lofi Gurl @Back ache @Md Mobashir Hossain @Almondo2025, @Dsuke1998AEOS, @Ternera, @Monsieur2137 @Asked42, @Sheminghui.WU, @excelblue (if you want yourself removed or someone else added to this list, please inquire here) A revision has been requested. Here is a list of what to do. (If/when you intend to start working on it, please Subscribe to this section and to this talk page, and post reply messages here when you started and finished editing) See below: 1. add a second source and expand correspondingly 2. find who submitted this for review with a solo source, and scream something meaningful into their talk page thanks Questions about the above? Ask. If possible, please address the above issues then resubmit the article for another review (by replacing {{tasks}} in the article with {{review}}). This talk page will be updated with subsequent reviews. |
Revision 4857985 of this article has been reviewed by Gryllida (talk · contribs) and found not ready at 10:39, 17 May 2025 (UTC).
Comments by reviewer: Hi @George Ho @Wikiwide @BigKrow @Lofi Gurl @Back ache @Md Mobashir Hossain @Almondo2025, @Dsuke1998AEOS, @Ternera, @Monsieur2137 @Asked42, @Sheminghui.WU, @excelblue (if you want yourself removed or someone else added to this list, please inquire here) A revision has been requested. Here is a list of what to do. (If/when you intend to start working on it, please Subscribe to this section and to this talk page, and post reply messages here when you started and finished editing) See below: 1. add a second source and expand correspondingly 2. find who submitted this for review with a solo source, and scream something meaningful into their talk page thanks Questions about the above? Ask. If possible, please address the above issues then resubmit the article for another review (by replacing {{tasks}} in the article with {{review}}). This talk page will be updated with subsequent reviews. |
New Jersey Transit Strike Violation unlikely 38.3% similarity goodmorningamerica.com/news/story/new-jersey-transit-strike-underway-350000-commuters-scramble-121836423
New Jersey Transit Strike Violation unlikely 38.3% similarity goodmorningamerica.com/news/story/new-jersey-transit-strike-underway-350000-commuters-scramble-121836423
@Wikiwide, @Gryllida BigKrow (talk) 21:49, 17 May 2025 (UTC)
- Hi @BigKrow
- I already have the link to check. It has been part of the review template since April 22, 2025 as I added it there.
- The "38%" number is pretty high. I am not sure why it says "violation is unlikely". This decision does not sound very wise.
- Also, 8% or 38%, but the number is not fully informative as it does not indicate which violations are enclosed in quotation marks and which are not.
- I can give an example. One of the quotes flagged is "estimates that it can only carry approximately 20% of current rail customers". This is a bit of a dummy. Most words in it are not uniquely phrased, nor they carry a unique meaning. It could be reworded to "notes that it could cope with "approximately 20%" of the usual rail capacity". Then the quote is shortened a lot and plagiarism is reduced.
- In my opinion what could help is highlighting/marking (in yellow, or bold, or whatever) the phrases in the article that are copyright violations, that are 1. not enclosed in quotation marks, or 2. (in your judgment) quoted into quotation marks but should potentially be rewordes in one's own words.
- I would happily carry out this edit for the article, but during the weekend I am not at my desktop and cannot have more than one tab open comfortably.
- Hope it helps. Gryllida (talk) 05:15, 18 May 2025 (UTC)
- A note on the use of Earwig and the need for clarity around plagiarism and copyright violations:
- Earwig's Copyvio Detector is a helpful tool meant to assist both authors and reviewers in identifying not just blatant plagiarism or copyright violations (copyvio), but also subtler forms of non-original content reuse, including what some refer to as "scuffing;" the superficial rewording of source material without producing original writing.
- The tool itself is not authoritative, and its conclusions (e.g., “violation unlikely”) have no standing in Wikinews policy. Results from Earwig should be treated as prompts for further scrutiny, not as final judgments. Similarly, the long-standing norm of avoiding more than three consecutive words from a source is a useful guideline, not a hard rule; exceptions do occur depending on context, such as formal titles that are three or more words.
- Ultimately, a full, independent, human review is required to assess whether an article contains plagiarism or violates copyright. Tools like Earwig can support that process, but they cannot replace editorial judgment or knowledge of Wikinews’ standards.
- Given recent issues and ongoing confusion, there is a clear need for the community to work toward a shared, comprehensive understanding of plagiarism, copyvio, and our expectations for originality. The goal should not be to test the limits of what might pass undetected, but to ensure all content is written in our own words—guided by the principles of accurate, original, and verifiable journalism.
- I encourage everyone to read Wikinews:Plagiarism, Wikinews talk:Plagiarism, and participate in the discussion there about how we define plagiarism. —Michael.C.Wright (Talk/Reviewer) 14:15, 19 May 2025 (UTC)
RR: distance from source
Hi @George Ho @Wikiwide @BigKrow @Lofi Gurl @Back ache @Md Mobashir Hossain @Almondo2025, @Dsuke1998AEOS, @Ternera, @Monsieur2137 @Asked42, @Sheminghui.WU, @excelblue (if you want yourself removed or someone else added to this list, please inquire here) A revision has been requested. Here is a list of what to do. (If/when you intend to start working on it, please Subscribe to this section and to this talk page, and post reply messages here when you started and finished editing) See below:
1) Suggest writing something like NJ Transit canceled both bus and train services for the concerts of Shakira, a Colombian singer, which he was performing at MetLife Stadium on Thursday and Friday. and citing https://www.instagram.com/p/DIxgy9kM1bL/ as an additional source (required login, yet at least it confirms who on earth that person is)
Sorry cannot do it as substantial edit. Gryllida (talk) 11:11, 18 May 2025 (UTC)
- Correction: "she" Gryllida (talk) 11:18, 18 May 2025 (UTC)
- Wikiwide did it thanks Gryllida (talk) 12:08, 18 May 2025 (UTC)
Review of revision 4858307 [Passed]
| |
Revision 4858307 of this article has been reviewed by Gryllida (talk · contribs) and has passed its review at 12:04, 18 May 2025 (UTC).
Comments by reviewer: checked copyright OK verified content OK revised for WN:IP (put strike descriptions towards page top and strike prelude/postlude towards page bottom) WN:TENSE (a few verbs in past tense) requested 1 edit for distance to source WN:Copyright i.e. clarify that Shakira reference elaborated on meaning of quotes so that the content is presented both inside of them and outside of them pretty well. i considered the penthouse and the private carrier quotes essential to convey the situation. now i'm happy with the result. i'll continue to monitor the page for 24 hours in case of further suggested edits but please tag my nick if you'd like me to sight edits. thanks. The reviewed revision should automatically have been edited by removing {{Review}} and adding {{Publish}} at the bottom, and the edit sighted; if this did not happen, it may be done manually by a reviewer. |
Revision 4858307 of this article has been reviewed by Gryllida (talk · contribs) and has passed its review at 12:04, 18 May 2025 (UTC).
Comments by reviewer: checked copyright OK verified content OK revised for WN:IP (put strike descriptions towards page top and strike prelude/postlude towards page bottom) WN:TENSE (a few verbs in past tense) requested 1 edit for distance to source WN:Copyright i.e. clarify that Shakira reference elaborated on meaning of quotes so that the content is presented both inside of them and outside of them pretty well. i considered the penthouse and the private carrier quotes essential to convey the situation. now i'm happy with the result. i'll continue to monitor the page for 24 hours in case of further suggested edits but please tag my nick if you'd like me to sight edits. thanks. The reviewed revision should automatically have been edited by removing {{Review}} and adding {{Publish}} at the bottom, and the edit sighted; if this did not happen, it may be done manually by a reviewer. |
Neutrality, balance, and sourcing
I note the following issues with this article as it is being archived: The article presents the union’s position in significantly more depth than NJ Transit’s, including multiple quotes and detailed criticisms of spending, while NJ Transit’s perspective is limited and lacks comparable context. This imbalance affects neutrality and should be addressed in future coverage by providing roughly equivalent detail for both sides and clearly attributing any value-laden language as opinion.
Additionally, one listed source is an Instagram post from Shakira promoting her concert dates. This is promotional content and does not support any verifiable fact in the article. In the future, sources must be used in accordance with WN:CS, which states: "Only cite sources used for information — do not add sources if you did not include any information from them."Michael.C.Wright (Talk/Reviewer) 01:33, 19 October 2025 (UTC)