Comments:Georgian woman celebrates 130th birthday

From Wikinews, the free news source you can write!
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Back to article

Wikinews commentary.svg

This page is for commentary on the news. If you wish to point out a problem in the article (e.g. factual error, etc), please use its regular collaboration page instead. Comments on this page do not need to adhere to the Neutral Point of View policy. Please remain on topic and avoid offensive or inflammatory comments where possible. Try thought-provoking, insightful, or controversial. Civil discussion and polite sparring make our comments pages a fun and friendly place. Please think of this when posting.

Use the "Start a new discussion" button just below to start a new discussion. If the button isn't there, wait a few seconds and click this link: Refresh.

Start a new discussion

Comments from feedback form - "seems a little bit of a waste ..."

seems a little bit of a waste of space to me

95.148.251.205 (talk)19:20, 11 July 2010

Comments from feedback form - "This is a FAKER AND THIS IS 10..."

This is a FAKER AND THIS IS 100% FALSE.

76.17.118.157 (talk)22:15, 8 July 2010

And you have proof of this? Sources?

DragonFire1024 (Talk to the Dragon)01:40, 9 July 2010

It's yet another claim of extreme longevity coming from a country with no reliable documentation, pushed by a family that welcomes the (financial) attention. The age is not independently verified by sources other than her passport - and she had an interest to make herself older in order to retire earlier. She may be old but not that old.

Update from the Associated Press: "Khvichava's 70-year-old son Mikhail apparently was born when his mother was 60." That says it all.

Hekerui (talk)09:39, 9 July 2010

Passport? Other documents say it too according to the AP. And this is in a country where benefits from old age are not like they are in the US. So unless there is valid arguments and or proof that she is not 130 years old, then it is all speculation. Also note that we never once said that she is 100% for sure to be 130 years old. And sorry...if she wanted to "retire" she would have done it before she was 85 years old.

DragonFire1024 (Talk to the Dragon)00:33, 10 July 2010

It is unlikely that this woman had a child at age 60. It's more likely that — given the poor record-keeping that existed at the time in her remote location and the faultiness of human memory — she's actually ~20 years younger than she claims to be. Which is still *really* old, mind you.

As a personal anecdote along similar lines: one of my coworkers has a parent in an assisted living home. While she was visiting him one day, one of the other old people living there claimed to be 99, before his son (who was also visiting) corrected him that he was actually 89. The old man isn't senile, it's just that age becomes less important to most people as they get older... before becoming more important again if you get very old:). I already have occasional trouble remembering how old I am, and I'm not yet thirty:P.

In this story there is no one who is still around from when this woman was young — and there hasn't been for several decades, so she has no one to remind her how old she really is.

Gopher65talk02:44, 10 July 2010
 
 
 
 

Comments from feedback form - "I need a little more proof to ..."

I need a little more proof to back up the story, but it would seem to be true.

198.145.81.148 (talk)05:59, 9 July 2010