Wikinews:Wikilawyering

From Wikinews, the free news source you can write!
(Redirected from Wikinews:WL)
Jump to: navigation, search

Wikilawyering is a term used mainly to indicate inappropriate use of pseudo-legal technicalities with respect to Wikinews policies. It can also be used to assert that certain arguments made in one's self-defense are, regardless of the specifics, based on a technical interpretation of policy, rather than the underlying principles and goals of Wikinews:Policies and guidelines.

Wikinews Policies and Guidelines

Neutral point of view
Content guide
Style guide

Administrators
Arbitration Committee

Accreditation policy
Archive conventions
Avoid weasel words
User blocking policy
Bots
Cite sources
Conflict of interest
Copyright
Dispute resolution
Criteria for deletion
Criteria for speedy deletion
Don't disrupt Wikinews
  to illustrate a point

Fair use
Image use policy
Naming conventions
Original reporting
Privilege expiry policy
Page protection policy
Reviewing articles
Three revert rule
Username policy

Etiquette

Policies and guidelines at Wikinews are intended to be interpreted in a commonsense manner which expresses the purpose of the policy or which tends toward resolution of disputes. Typically wikilawyering attempts to raise some procedural or evidentiary point in the manner it might be raised in legal proceedings, often using conventional common law reasoning—under the false assumption that administrators or the arbcom are obligated to follow the same rules of procedure as an actual court of law. Occasionally such an objection might concern some question of fairness, but often it serves only to evade the issue or obstruct the crafting of a workable solution.

Please note that the word carries a negative connotation and should not be applied lightly or indescriminately.

See also Wikipedia:Wikilawyering and related legal terms.