City Planning Board postpones decision on Buffalo, N.Y. hotel proposal
Thursday, March 2, 2006
City of Buffalo's Planning Board voted to table the Elmwood Village hotel Proposal, postponing voting on legislation for up to 30 days.— In an unanimous vote, the
The Board said its decision was due to the lack of public involvement, saying that there have not been enough meetings.
The Elmwood Village Hotel is a proposed project by Savarino Construction Services Corporation and was designed by Karl Frizlen of The Frizlen Group. The hotel would be placed on Elmwood and Forest Avenues in Buffalo, New York. In order for the hotel to be built, at least five buildings, that include both businesses and residents, must be demolished.
The Forever Elmwood Corp. is a Buffalo-based non-profit organization founded in 1994. Justin Azzarella, the Executive Director for the organization voiced support for the proposal, stating: "I am here today to lend Forever Elmwood's support the hotel project. Particularly, Forever Elmwood is encouraged by the fact that this building follows the more stringent Elmwood Village Design Guidelines. We have been speaking with Savarino Construction, and they have promised us [Forever Elmwood] that they will engage the community further, including the surrounding Block Clubs and businesses. For that reason, while Forever Elmwood is in support of this project and the type of project that it is, we are asking also that the project be tabled so that the community can be further engaged. Specifically the surrounding Block clubs which include the Granger, Claremont, Asland and The Lincoln Parkway Block Clubs."
"Because of the excellent work that Karl does and the game plan that they have, I think its an ideal use of this particular location. I think that this particular type of development needs to be encouraged and promoted as opposed to roadblocked," said a man who owns five properties near the proposal site.
However, Evelyn Bencinich, a resident of Granger Place and whose house would be located directly behind the hotel said, "My property value will be depreciated or non-existent because no one is going to want to live behind a multi-story hotel. We are facing up to a year of noisy and dangerous demolition and construction. Children, pets and even drunk rebellers could wander on site and get hurt. Traffic tie-ups caused by large machinery and garbage bins is inevitable. Where will pedestrians walk? We could experience increased unsanitary flooding in our yards and basements due to the digging and cementing for the underground parking garage. Rats will be displaced into the immediate neighborhoods and be in great abundance. Once we get past the year of nightmare construction, what if you build it and they don't come? We could ultimately have a seven million dollar rooming house on our corner."
Patty Morris, co-owner of Don Apparel with Nancy Pollina at 1119 Elmwood also asked that the project be tabled saying, "this has only been public knowledge for less than two weeks and the public never saw the redesign. How can you vote on anything that no one has seen yet? The Board cut off Morris saying, "so specifically you don't have any problem with it [the design] you just..." Morris then said, "Oh I am totally against this project, but thats besides the point isn't it."
Planning board wants hotel smaller
The planning board is also concerned that the current design may still be too big.
At one point Board member Susan Curran Hoyt said, "we know you've cut down your number of rooms on this project, but we still see it doesn't seem to fit the description of a 'botique' hotel," and asked Eva Hassett, Vice President of Savarino Construction, "we wonder if you could reduce the rooms further."
"One thing I didn't talk about was the price levels of these rooms and that will be important to know. The room rate will be somewhere between US$120 and $160 a night, which is about the same price of the Hampton Inn down town and the smaller you make the hotel, the more expensive the rooms will get. We believe that we've made a good compromise in terms of the size of the hotel and perhaps botique means different things to different people," said Hassett.
The board was also concerned that there is not enough parking asking, "are there alternative plans for valet parking off-site, in the event that you have a full hotel or a large event going on?"
"We are exploring several possibilities with respect to additional parking for valet and parking near-by," replied Hassett. "We are also exploring the possibility of using the rear of 1105 Elmwood for additional parking, which would give us an additional ten or eleven spaces."
The new design has a total of 55 parking spaces for 72 rooms, with 39 of them underground and the rest on ground level.
Hassett also said that a "parking study" will be done on the area.
Concerns that the second floor of the hotel will be too close to the property of 605 Forest were also brought up. The board asked how far the hotel would be from the property and Karl Frizlen replied saying it would "be approximately five feet from the property line," but he also admitted that, "I do not know exactly how close the house next door" will be from the hotel, but did say "I think the house is about four or five feet away from the property line and we [the hotel] sit right on the property line."
The board is concerned the setback from the property is not enough saying the space between the building and the hotel is "pretty narrow."
Common Council also tables hotel proposal
The City's Common Council also agreed to table the proposal also citing the need for more public engagement and the need for more organizations to respond including the Buffalo Preservation Board and the Office of Historic Preservation.
During that meeting, Hassett also said the proposal to try and get a variance to obtain the properties of 605 and 607 Forest were "now off the agenda."
The Common Council is expected to meet and hold a public hearing about the project and the rezoning of the properties to be demolished (1119-1121 Elmwood) on Tuesday March 7, 2006 at 2:00 p.m. in Council Chambers at City Hall. At the moment the properties are not zoned for a hotel.
- "Residents and business owners attend "private" meeting on Buffalo, N.Y. hotel proposal" — Wikinews, February 28, 2006
- "Eva Hassett, VP of Savarino Construction Services Corp. answers questions on Buffalo, N.Y. hotel redesign" — Wikinews, February 27, 2006
- "Alternative to controversial hotel proposed to Buffalo, N.Y. business owners and residents" — Wikinews, February 23, 2006
- "Hotel development proposal could displace Buffalo, NY business owners" — Wikinews, February 17, 2006
- Citywide Design and Site Plan, Article XXVIII(PDF). These are the guidelines that any proposed development in the Elmwood Village should follow before development, during and after.