Judge strikes down same-sex marriage ban in California
Tuesday, March 15, 2005
Kramer said the two California laws violated the state's constitutional guarantees of privacy and a legal concept called due process - which tries to ensure each person is treated equally by the law. "The denial of marriage to same-sex couples appears impermissibly arbitrary," Kramer wrote in the opinion released Monday.
In his decision, Kramer cited United States Supreme Court case law ranging from Brown v. Board of Education to Lawrence v. Texas in a step-by-step dismantling of legal arguments against same-sex marriage. Including the following excerpts:
- Traditional definition of marriage: "Same-sex marriage cannot be prohibited solely because California has always done so before."
- With California's domestic partner laws, gays don't need marriage: "That California has granted marriage-like rights to same-sex couples points to the conclusion that there is no rational state interest in denying them the rites of marriage as well."
- The purpose of marriage is procreation: "The obvious natural and social reality [is] that one does not have to be married to procreate, nor does one have to procreate in order to be married."
Kramer, a Catholic Republican Judge appointed by Pete Wilson, California's previous conservative governor, issued a "stay" on his order, making it a tentative decision by delaying its implementation for 60 days to allow the same-sex marriage opponents time to file an appeal to his ruling. The case is widely expected to be brought before the California Supreme Court.
Less than a year ago, the state's Supreme Court annulled more than 4,000 same-sex marriages which took place in San Francisco County in 2004. The court did not rule on the constitutionality of same-sex marriages, but ruled more narrowly that San Francisco mayor Gavin Newsom overstepped his authority by unilaterally deciding not to follow state laws he did not agree with instead of challenging the laws in court, which is the proper legal way to overturn or affirm laws in California and much of the United States.
- Text of decision by Judge Richard A. Kramer (PDF):. "Tentative Decision on Applications for Writ of Mandate and Motions for Summary Judgment" — , March 14, 2005
- "Summary Box: California's marriage laws struck down" — , March 14, 2005
- David Kravetz. "Judge in gay marriage case is a Catholic Republican appointee" — , March 14, 2005
- Dean E. Murphy. "California Judge Voids Ban on Gay Marriage" — , March 15, 2005
- Bob Egelko. "Court invalidates California's ban on same-sex marriage" — , March 14, 2005