On the campaign trail in the USA, May 2016
Monday, June 13, 2016
The following is the first edition of a monthly series chronicling the U.S. 2016 presidential election. It features original material compiled throughout the previous month after an overview of the month's biggest stories.
In this month's edition on the campaign trail: a former Republican congressman briefly joins the Libertarian Party and runs for vice president; the Democratic Party names its National Convention Platform Drafting Committee amid controversy; and Wikinews interviews a candidate who had a surprisingly strong performance in the West Virginia Democratic presidential primary.
On the campaign trail in early May, the Republican Party primary race grew more contentious as it reached its final stages. On the same day as the May 3 Indiana primary, Republican front-runner Donald Trump, who held a sizable delegate lead over his two remaining primary challengers, Senator of Texas and Ohio Governor , cited the to accuse Cruz's of involvement in the of President . Cruz, whom Trump branded as "Lyin' Ted," attacked Trump as a "pathological liar" and "serial philanderer." Trump won Indiana by a large margin, prompting the second place Cruz to end his campaign. Thereafter, both the media and Chairman christened Trump as the presumptive nominee, even though he had yet to secure the requisite number of National Convention delegates. The next day, Kasich finally suspended his candidacy. As Trump pivoted into general election mode, he faced a vocal within the party and a significant polling deficit against the Democrats. A national CNN/ORC poll showed Trump trailing Democratic front-runner by double digits. Nevertheless, unlike the GOP, the outcome of the Democratic primary race remained undecided. Although Clinton maintained a significant delegate lead, a CNN poll showed her ahead of sole rival, Senator Bernie Sanders of Vermont, by only eight points. In fact, Sanders won the Indiana Democratic primary, making nine victories out of the latest fourteen contests to that point.
Commencing his general election campaign, Trump announced he would participate in fundraising after self-funding his primary campaign. He named former presidential rival, retired neurosurgeon Paul Ryan said he would not commit to endorsing Trump. He called for Trump "to set aside bullying, [...] belittlement, and appeal to higher aspirations." Ryan's comments drew criticism from former House Speaker Newt Gingrich and former 2016 presidential candidate Mike Huckabee, among others. However, former candidates and , as well as former Presidents George W. Bush and George H. W. Bush, all said they could not support Trump's candidacy. 2012 Republican presidential nominee Mitt Romney and editor both called for an independent presidential candidate to run as an alternative to Trump. Ryan called this "a disaster," and sought unity by inviting Trump to a Republican congressional leadership meeting and offering to step down as chair of the GOP National Convention if Trump so desired. Despite the internal strife, Trump continued his focus on the general election, branding Clinton as "crooked Hillary," and attacking her for "want[ing] to abolish the ." He also pivoted on policies, advocating for a rise in the federal and taxes on the wealthy. The campaign announced that five or six names were on the vice presidential shortlist including former presidential candidate . showed Trump leading or close behind Clinton in head-to-head match ups in Pennsylvania, Ohio, and Florida. Clinton won the caucus in Guam and the campaign shifted to West Virginia and Nebraska. On the eve of the May 10 primaries, Cruz, still on the ballot in Nebraska, announced he might restart his campaign if he won the state. Instead, Trump won Nebraska by a wide margin and won West Virginia by an even wider margin. On the Democratic side, Sanders won West Virginia as voters turned on Clinton after she expressed unencouraging views about the . ABC News exit polling there revealed nearly half of Sanders supporters said they would vote for Trump if Clinton won the nomination.to head a group to search for a running mate. And, in a show of pro- sentiment, he tweeted a photo of himself with a on . Still, the Republican Party remained divided.
Vice President Joe Biden, who had been expected to mount a 2016 campaign until he ruled it out in late 2015, admitted in an interview with ABC that he had planned to run for president in 2016 but the plans derailed upon the death of his son . He revealed Senator as his preferred running mate and endorsed her for the Democratic vice presidential nomination. Senate Minority Leader Harry Reid of Nevada cautioned Democrats against nominating a sitting Senator like Warren to avoid decreasing the number of Democrats in the Senate. Trump launched an assault on Warren, referring to her as "goofy" and for a previous claim of ancestry. On May 12, Trump had his much anticipated meeting with Ryan. Afterwards, the two issued a joint statement calling the meeting "a very positive step toward unification." Ryan still withheld his endorsement though Trump asked Ryan to remain as chair of the National Convention. Polls from mid-May showed Trump edging closer to Clinton in national head-to-head match ups, as Trump faced a barrage of controversies. Both Clinton and Romney called on Trump to release his tax records. He said he might release them, but maintained it was "none of [the public's] business." Media reports also scrutinized Trump for allegedly acting as his own publicist in the early 1990's. He denied the allegations outright. Next, The New York Times published an exposé about Trump's treatment of women throughout the years. The validity of the story came into question when the lead interviewee claimed The Times had taken her account out of context. On May 17, Trump easily won the Oregon primary. The next day, for the first time in months, a Fox News poll showed him with a national lead over Clinton. That same day, he released a list of eleven judges whom he would consider nominating to the U.S. Supreme Court. He later received an endorsement from the . In the Democratic race, Sanders won the Oregon primary and narrowly lost to Clinton in Kentucky. He was also able to add five of his supporters to the Democratic National Convention platform drafting committee, ensuring greater influence over the party platform. Clinton rejected a debate with him and announced there would be no further primary debates. Trump offered to debate Sanders, which Sanders accepted, though Trump later backed out. Clinton went on the offensive against Trump for his past business bankruptcies, saying he "could bankrupt America like he's bankrupted his companies." She won the Washington primary on May 24. However, the next day, an Inspector General report said she did not comply with State Department policy when she sent official e-mails on a private server while Secretary of State.
Following a victory in the Washington Republican primary, Trump traveled to New Mexico, where the sitting Republican governor snubbed his event. Trump attacked Martinez during the rally, later asking, "If I have a Republican that’s not on my side, why should I be particularly nice to that person?" Shortly thereafter, during a speech in California, he renewed attacks against Romney, Cruz, Kristol, and Jeb Bush. Former rival Marco Rubio announced he would release the delegates he won during the primary to support Trump and said he would be willing to go on the campaign trail for Trump, if asked. Rubio also apologized to Trump for derogatory comments he made earlier in the campaign. Trump mathematically secured the Republican nomination, when an uncommitted slate of delegates in North Dakota committed to supporting him. Meanwhile, the Libertarian Party commenced its and nominated for president, on the second ballot, former New Mexico Governor Gary Johnson, the party's 2012 presidential nominee. Also on the second ballot, for vice president, the party nominated Johnson's pre-selected running mate, former Massachusetts Governor , who had just left the Republican Party to become a Libertarian. Trump called Johnson a "fringe candidate." Johnson was not the last such candidate introduced in late May. Seemingly ending his search for an alternative to Trump, Kristol tweeted that he had found an "impressive" independent candidate. Bloomberg reported the candidate was little-known writer of the . On the final day of May, Trump held a press conference in which he revealed the veterans charities he donated to after raising $5.6 million during a fundraiser he held in January in lieu of attending a debate. Trump excoriated the national press for its coverage of his campaign and referred to one reporter as "sleaze." With the June 7 California primary ahead, Clinton received the endorsement of California . The latest polls showed her with a two point advantage over Sanders in the state. In the average, she led Trump in the general election nationally by 1.5%.
Ex GOP congressman joins LP, seeks VP, then leaves
As soon as Donald Trump secured the Republican presidential nomination, Libertarian Party (LP) membership applications doubled. Longtime Republican consultant Michigan, were among those who left the GOP in May to find a new home in the LP. While Matalin enthusiastically backed Libertarian presidential runner-up Austin Petersen, and Weld won the party's vice presidential nomination; Bentivolio, who had endorsed Dr. Ben Carson for president before joining the party, had a much different experience., former Massachusetts governor William Weld, and former Congressman of
"It was suggested by a few supporters I run [for vice president] as a libertarian," says Bentivolio, a teacher and veteran of theand wars, who earned the moniker "the accidental Congressman" after his surprising 2012 election, "I briefly entertained the idea of running and spent time investigating the party."
Bentivolio, 64, unexpectedly won the Republican nomination to represent Thaddeus McCotter, a 2012 presidential candidate, was unable to run for re-election after his petitions to qualify for the primary ballot were deemed fraudulent. Upon his victory in the general election, Bentivolio went to Washington, joining the and the . He took an active role in introducing and sponsoring successful legislation, becoming, according to an historian of the House, one of the most effective freshmen Congressmen of recent times. listed him as the most transparent Republican freshman in the . Nevertheless, during his single term, he frequently bucked the party leadership, voting against a resolution to the , calling for the of President Barack Obama, and agreeing to seek congressional hearings over . In 2014, Bentivolio lost his seat to attorney , a primary opponent with a fundraising edge and the backing of the Republican establishment. After leaving Congress, Bentivolio suffered financial difficulties and had to file for in 2015, partly the result of his expensive primary campaign against Trott.in 2012, after the sitting Congressman,
When Bentivolio joined the LP in May, he filed a Form 2 with the Federal Election Commission to run for vice president. Libertarian national chairman encouraged Bentivolio to run for his old congressional seat in addition to vice president. This was not well received by the local Libertarian Party, which feared such a run would violate Michigan's ; the same law that prevented Gary Johnson from appearing on the ballot in 2012. As a consequence, the local party nominated another candidate to run for the seat.
"The district delegates [five in total] voted for another as the House candidate", recounts Bentivolio, "[the candidate's] wife was the deciding vote."
Afterwards, Bentivolio expressed doubt about the party platform, saying it amounted to "judicial supremacy," which he rejects, referencing the 1857, which affirmed the rights of slaveholders. He added, "I am 100% and an and many in the Libertarian Party are and support slavery in their immigration policy." He cited these as his reasons for ending his vice presidential campaign.
After Gary Johnson and William Weld won the party's presidential and vice presidential nominations at the 2016 Libertarian National Convention, Bentivolio offered his perspective on Johnson and Weld. Though he considered Johnson, "a nice guy and honest," he felt Johnson "thinks government has all the answers." In contrast, Bentivolio said he personally believes "government is the problem" and only supports "a government within the strict limitations clearly expressed in the Constitution." He described Weld, amember who proposed strict measures as governor, as someone who "supports big government."
Bentivolio has left the LP and now is an independent. He remains undecided on whether to support Donald Trump for president. To help him decide, he is currently researching claims of a woman named "Katie Johnson" who filed a lawsuit accusing Trump of rape. Trump's attorneys dismiss the suit as a hoax.
DNC aims for unity with Platform Drafting Committee picks; controversy ensues
Every four years, the Democratic Party holds its National Convention, nominating a presidential ticket and conducting official business. One important item is the drafting of ato express the party's principles and vision for the future. A special committee is formed to draft the document. In May, fifteen individuals were named to the committee. Democratic National Committee (DNC) chair selected four of the members while the two presidential candidates picked the remaining eleven in proportion to the votes each candidate received in the primaries. Hillary Clinton, the party's presidential front-runner, selected six. Bernie Sanders chose five, though the DNC rejected one of his original picks, a union leader, leading to charges of anti-union bias in the DNC. Still, upon the release of the names, magazine argued Sanders' input provided the committee with a " majority." Wikinews was able to reach out to one of Sanders' picks to see what he planned for the platform.
McKibben, a Schumann Distinguished Scholar at climate change awareness organization , tells Wikinews that his Vermont roots may explain why Sanders selected him for the committee. However, McKibben has worked with Sanders previously on climate and energy issues, and The Boston Globe has described him as "probably the nation’s leading environmentalist."who co-founded the
"I'd like to see [the platform] reflect the fact that since the last election the planet's climate has deteriorated dramatically, with record temperatures, melting ice, and dying coral", says McKibben, "So that means we need to move more aggressively, both to cut our reliance on fossil fuels and to boost renewable energy."
McKibben is not the only member who prioritizes environmental issues. Browner, who headed the EPA during the entire presidency of Bill Clinton, has worked under President Obama as the director of the . While the environment is given a strong emphasis, Sanders has raised the point that labor representation on the committee is lacking.
In 2012, union leaders Donna Harris-Aikens of theand Thea Lee of the were on the committee. This year, the only union leader is Booth of the . Sanders attempted to include executive director , but Wasserman Schultz vetoed the pick. Sanders, in a press conference, accused the DNC of "not want[ing] representatives of labor unions on the platform drafting committee." The DNC rejected the charge.
"We worked carefully with both campaigns to ensure overall balance and representation," says DNC spokeswoman April Mellody, "[we] have 100% confidence that the views of our allies in the Labor community will be well represented in our Party’s platform as they have always been."
Amid the division, McKibben expresses hope that though the platform is often "forgotten not long after it's written," perhaps the 2016 platform "will play a role in uniting the party."
The committee is set to convene at the Philadelphia.July 25–28 in
- DNC Platform Drafting Committee
Interview with overachieving West Virginia Democratic protest candidate
In the May 10 West Virginia Democratic primary, Bernie Sanders defeated Hillary Clinton 51.4 percent to 35.8 percent. Of the remaining 13 percent, nearly nine went to little-known protest candidate, a attorney who entered the race to challenge President Obama's energy policies. Wikinews reached out to Farrell to ask a few questions about the campaign.
During the campaign, Farrell did not hold any fundraisers and his only spending was the $2,500 filing fee to appear on the ballot. He believes Obama's policies, which Clinton supports, have hurt the coal industry, a major sector of West Virginia's economy. Many West Virginians, even Democrats, share this view. While mining still makes up 17 percent of West Virginia's ABC News exit polls from the primary, only 26 percent of West Virginia Democrats want to continue Obama's policies.(compared to 3 percent nationally), since 2009, coal production has declined around 45 percent in the south part of the state. 332 mines have closed and almost 10,000 jobs or 35 percent of those in the industry, have been lost. West Virginia's unemployment is the worst in the nation. According to
Although registered Democrats outnumber Republicans roughly 577,000 to 378,000 in West Virginia, Republican presidential candidates have won the state in every election since. ABC exit polls indicate a third of Democrats plan to vote in November for Trump, who has campaigned in favor of the coal industry. Trump is popular in West Virginia, having won 77 percent in the state's GOP primary. He holds a 27 point lead over Clinton in the latest head-to-head match up.
West Virginia Democrats have a history of going against the national party establishment. Notably, prison inmatewon 41 percent in the 2012 primary against Obama, who was seeking re-election. Judd was on the ballot again in 2016, but received only 1.8 percent of the vote. Judd's 2012 performance was one of the reasons Farrell cited for entered the race. In addition, he told the Charleston Gazette–Mail back in January that the candidates running did not share "West Virginia values." He had hoped to secure some national convention delegates but just fell short. He was able to come in second place in the coal-rich , where he outpaced Clinton 23.7 percent to 21.4 percent.
With Wikinews, Farrell discusses, his specific problem with Obama's energy policy, what he is looking for in a presidential candidate, and his views on Trump.
((WSS)) How were you able to get over 8% of the vote in the West Virginia Democratic Primary?
- Farrell: The 2016 Democratic nominees for President of the United States support President Barack Obama's executive order which we disparagingly refer to as the "war on coal." West Virginia voters take exception to abruptly bankrupting our economy without a comprehensive plan to rebuild our infrastructure. The presumptive nominee, Hillary Clinton, lost all 55 counties in West Virginia. Voters did not cast a ballot for me; they cast a ballot for the candidate with "WV" listed after his name in protest to Mrs. Clinton's energy policy.
((WSS)) Do you plan on supporting the Democratic presidential nominee come November?
- Farrell: No. I will support the candidate that adopts a platform that rebuilds our economy which President Obama dismantled and pledges to pass legislation during his/her first "100 days."
((WSS)) What are your thoughts on presumptive Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump?
- Farrell: Mrs. Clinton made the campaign promise to put "coal miners and coal companies out of business." Mr. Trump says he will fight for West Virginia. Even if Mr. Trump is full of shit, I choose to fight rather than surrender. Most of the southern coal fields of West Virginia stand with me.
- "U.S. Congressman Thad McCotter aborts write-in campaign" — Wikinews, June 4, 2012
- "Prison inmate wins 41% against President Obama in West Virginia primary" — Wikinews, May 10, 2012
- "Latest 2016 Democratic Presidential Primary Polls" — , June 12, 2016 (accessed)
- "AFL–CIO Donna Harris-aikens" — , June 9, 2016 (accessed)
- "AFL–CIO Thea Lee" — , June 9, 2016 (accessed)
- "Philadelphia 2016. Let's Make History Again" — , June 9, 2016 (accessed)
- "West Virginia Primary Results" — , June 9, 2016 (accessed)
- "Voter Registration Totals" — , June 9, 2016 (accessed)
- "William F. Weld" — , June 9, 2016 (accessed)
- "Election 2016 — Democratic Delegate Count" — , June 9, 2016 (accessed)
- "General Election: Trump vs. Clinton" — , June 9, 2016 (accessed)
- "Politics1 News Updates" — , June 9, 2016 (accessed)
- "2016 Presidential Primaries Results" — , June 8, 2016 (last updated)
- Daniel Strauss. "Sanders accuses DNC of keeping labor union representation off platform committee" — , June 1, 2016
- Eli Stokols, Nolan D. McCaskill. "Trump taunts media to its face" — , May 31, 2016
- AllahPundit. "Trump on Susana Martinez: If a Republican’s not on my side, why should I be particularly nice to them?" — , May 31, 2016
- "Trump wins enough delegates for Republican nomination" — , May 26, 2016
- Michael Brendan Dougherty. "Why 'Crooked Hillary' is likely to stick" — , May 24, 2016
- Jennifer Harper. "Austin Petersen: The potential of a pro-life Libertarian gets noticed" — , May 24, 2016
- John Nichols. "The Democratic Platform Committee Now Has a Progressive Majority. Thanks, Bernie Sanders." — , May 24, 2016
- Ben Kamisar. "Sanders names Cornel West, Keith Ellison to DNC platform committee" — , May 23, 2016
- Robert Eno. "5 Statist Positions That Should Make Libertarians Run From Bill Weld" — , May 19, 2016
- Eliza Collins. "Woman in NYT piece about Trump's mistreatment of women fires back" — , May 16, 2016
- Caitlin Yilek. "Trump on Warren: 'You mean Pocahontas?'" — , May 15,2016
- Alan Rappeport. "Protest Candidate, Paul Farrell, Wins 9 Percent of West Virginia Primary Vote" — , May 11, 2016
- Heidi M. Przybyla. "Sanders defeats Clinton in West Virginia" — , May 10, 2016
- Rebecca Savransky. "Exit polls: Nearly half of W.Va. Sanders backers would vote Trump" — , May 10, 2016
- "West Virginia Democratic Primary Exit Poll Results" — , May 10, 2016
- "Kerry Bentivolio Fec Form 2 Statement Of Candidacy" — , May 9, 2016
- Benjy Sarlin. "Trump Reverses Stances on Taxes, Wages as He Turns to Fall Election" — , May 5, 2016
- Ashe Schow. "Libertarian Party membership applications double after Trump becomes GOP nominee" — , May 4, 2016
- Tom Jensen. "Trump, Sanders lead in West Virginia" — , May 3, 2016
- David Martosko, Ryan Parry, and Hannah Parry. "Donald Trump denies woman's claims that she was raped by the tycoon and lawyer says the plaintiff may not be a real person" — , April 29, 2016
- "West Virginia" — , March 24, 2016 (last updated)
- David Gutman. "Huntington lawyer running for president" — , January 28, 2016
- Paul H. Tice. "Obama’s Appalachian Tragedy" — , November 30, 2015
- Don Gonyea. "West Virginia Tells The Story Of America's Shifting Political Climate" — , October 24, 2015
- David Shepardson, Robert Snell, and Chad Livengood. "Ex-Congressman Bentivolio files for bankruptcy" — , February 27, 2015
- "Congressional Record" — , December 10, 2014
- Betsy Woodruff. "Goodbye West Virginia" — , October 29, 2014
- Nicholas P. Fandos. "Trott topples Bentivolio in Mich. race" — , August 6, 2014
- Khalil AlHajal. "Republican members of Congress from Metro Detroit explain why they voted no on ending shutdown" — , October 17, 2013
- Henry Payne. "Can Krazy Kerry Bentivolio survive his own antics?" — , September 10, 2013
- "Democratic National Convention" — , July 12, 2012
- Anis Shivani (Facing cold, hard truths about global warming" — , May 30, 2010