Texas federal judge says drafting only men violates United States Constitution

Monday, February 25, 2019

On Friday, a federal judge in Texas ruled the United States federal government's practice of registering men but not women for the draft, or military conscription, is unconstitutional.

In response to a lawsuit by the men's rights group National Coalition for Men, U.S. District Judge Gray Miller ruled the male-only draft violated the Due Process Clause of the United States Constitution. He said the rationale for difference along gender lines from a previous Supreme Court ruling, that women were ineligible to serve in combat, no longer applies. Women, who make up 16% of the U.S. military enlisted and 18% of officers as of 2016, according to nonprofit CNA, have been serving official combat roles since 2015.

"While historical restrictions on women in the military may have justified past discrimination," reads Judge Miller's statement, "men and women are now 'similarly situated for purposes of a draft or registration for a draft.' [...] If there ever was a time to discuss 'the place of women in the Armed Services,' that time has passed."

By law, all male permanent residents of the United States over the age of 18 must register for the Selective Service System. This both renders them eligible for certain public services and identifies them for the draft, or military conscription, were a draft to be imposed.

Part of the judge's statement reads "the average woman could conceivably be better suited physically for some of today's combat positions than the average man, depending on which skills the position required. Combat roles no longer uniformly require sheer size or muscle." He went on to cite the Supreme Court ruling permitting same-sex marriage.

The ruling was a declaration, placing no injunction on the government to immediately change the Selective Service System.

There is currently a commission engaged to study the role of the draft, and the government asked Judge Miller to delay his ruling until after they made their recommendations, but he declined. USA Today noted the commission's scope allows it to advise including women in the draft or eliminating the draft entirely.

The last draft in the United States took place in 1973 during the Vietnam War.

Have an opinion on this story? Share it!

Sources

Gregory Korte. "With women in combat roles, a federal court rules the male-only draft unconstitutional" — USA Today, February 24, 2019
Ken Stone. "San Diego-Based Group Wins U.S. Suit: Male-Only Draft Unconstitutional" — Times of San Diego, February 24, 2019

George M. Reynolds and Amanda Shendruk. "Demographics of the U.S. Military" — Council on Foreign Relations, April 24, 2018

External links

"National Coalition for Men et al. v Selective Service System" — United States District Court, Southern District of Texas, February 22, 2019

Share this:

This page is archived, and is no longer publicly editable.

Articles presented on Wikinews reflect the specific time at which they were written and published, and do not attempt to encompass events or knowledge which occur or become known after their publication.

Got a correction? Add the template {{editprotected}} to the talk page along with your corrections, and it will be brought to the attention of the administrators.

Please note that due to our archival policy, we will not alter or update the content of articles that are archived, but will only accept requests to make grammatical and formatting corrections.

Note that some listed sources or external links may no longer be available online due to age.

The text of this article is licensed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 2.5 License